Tata Tigor vs Honda Amaze: Which Car to Choose?
When it comes to deciding between the Tata Tigor and the Honda Amaze, both cars offer unique advantages and disadvantages. This guide will help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences.
Initial Market Prices and Pricing Comparison
First, let's look at the pricing aspect. The Tata Tigor with an XMA AMT transmission (Automatic Manual Transmission) typically costs around 2 lakh (INR) less than the Honda Amaze with CVT (Continuously Variable Transmission). This price difference can be significant and can save you a substantial amount of money. However, it's important to remember that more expensive models or additional features can increase the cost.
Key Features and Comparisons
Safety and Maintenance
When it comes to safety, the Tata Tigor comes equipped with features that are streets ahead of the Honda Amaze. Tigor boasts advanced safety features which can provide you with greater peace of mind on the road. Additionally, Tatas are generally considered cheaper to maintain compared to Hondas. This can significantly impact your overall ownership costs and save you money in the long run.
Engine and Performance
The Tigor is powered by a 1.2-liter 3-cylinder engine that is known for its notchiness and performance. While it offers comparable fuel efficiency to the Honda Amaze, the Amaze’s 4-cylinder engine is generally more peppy and smooth. The CVT on the Honda Amaze makes for a more enjoyable driving experience, but the Tigor's AMT transmission can be a bit less refined.
Driving Experience and Comfort
Comfort and Cabin Space
When evaluating the driving experience, personal comfort is a crucial factor. Both the Tata Tigor and the Honda Amaze offer comparable fuel efficiency, but where the Tigor stands out is in its rear seats and suspension. You mentioned that the new Tigor had better rear seats and suspension, which was a highlight over the Honda Amaze. Additionally, the new Tigor's beige interiors and more spacious cabin contribute to a premium feel, making it a more comfortable choice for longer drives.
Interior and Design
The new Tigor's design is also an advantage, with clean lines and better-seated comfort. The old Tigor had a specific layout with black and grey interiors and cushioned seats, while the newer model has improvements in interior quality and design. The Honda Amaze, with its beige interior and straight dashboard, is visually spacious but may not offer the same premium feel as the Tigor. Both cars have their merits, but the Tigor's updated design speaks to a more modern and comfortable driving experience.
Maintenance and Resale Value
Tata cars have a reputation for a higher build quality, which can translate into better reliability and a smoother driving experience. However, it's important to consider the resale value of both cars. The Honda Amaze, being a bestseller, has a higher resale value due to its strong presence in the market. While Tata cars are reliable, they may not command as high a resale price as the Amaze.
Conclusion and Recommendation
Based on the factors discussed, the decision boils down to your budget and specific needs. If you are on a tight budget and have approximately 8 lakh (INR) to spend, the Tata Tigor is a solid choice. It offers value for money, good build quality, and a premium feel in the newer models. However, if you have an extra couple of lakhs to spare, the Honda Amaze is the better choice. The Amaze's smoother driving experience, premium feel, and higher resale value make it a more attractive option for those who prioritize these aspects.
One of your colleagues also tested the Tigor and the Amaze, and noted that the Tigor's rear seats and suspension were better. This aligns with your experience and can be a deciding factor in your decision.
Final Thoughts
Both cars have their pros and cons, but with a good understanding of what you prioritize in a car, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs. Whether you go for the Tata Tigor or the Honda Amaze, ensure you carefully consider the aspects that matter most to you—be it cost, comfort, or resale value.