Which is Best Among Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model S, and BMW i8?
When it comes to choosing an electric vehicle (EV), the Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model S, and BMW i8 offer unique features and experiences. While these cars are quite different, they also share key similarities that can help potential buyers make an informed decision. In this guide, we will compare these vehicles in terms of their design, performance, and driving experience.
Overview of the BMW i8
The BMW i8 is a pioneering hybrid electric vehicle (HEV) that combines both gasoline and electric power. Being no longer in production, finding a good used i8 can be a challenge. Although it has a sleek and stylish design, the i8's electric range is rather short, making it more suitable for very short trips. However, if you are looking for a car that offers a blend of performance and efficiency, the BMW i8 is still a noteworthy option.
Comparing the Tesla Model 3 and Model S
The Tesla Model 3 and Model S are both fully electric vehicles (EVs) and are quite similar in many aspects. If you were to compare them side by side, the differences would be subtle, making it easy to confuse the two.
Design and Screen
One of the most notable differences between the two models is the dashboard design. The Model S features a larger, central touchscreen, whereas the Model 3 incorporates just one screen. Many critics, including myself, find this design less user-friendly, as it requires you to look away from the road to find information. However, the Model S has an adjustable suspension, which may be more durable compared to the Model 3's suspension.
Performance and Price
Regarding performance, both models are highly capable. The Model S has an extended range version, which is worth the premium price for those who need it. On the other hand, the Model 3 offers a more budget-friendly alternative for those who prioritize cost savings. If you can tolerate the single-screen interface, the Model 3 can be a great choice. Additionally, the Model S can be resold as a used car, providing a compromise between a new and used vehicle.
My Personal Experience
As a personal user of both a Tesla Model 3 and a BMW i8, I have firsthand experience with these vehicles. The BMW i8 was initially more suitable for me due to my height and back issues, as its design did not accommodate my needs. On the other hand, I13 have purchased a Model 3 and find it highly responsive and comfortable.
One of the key advantages of the Tesla Model 3 is its extended range capability, with the option to install a 240-volt circuit for faster charging. This feature is crucial for long-distance travel. The Model 3, specifically the extended range rear-wheel drive version, performs similarly to the Model S in terms of features, but at a more affordable price point.
Regarding battery range, my Tesla Model 3 averages around 258 miles on a full charge, keeping the battery between 70-80% to preserve its life. The BMW i8, in contrast, has only 17 miles on electric power. The Model 3's 310 miles on a charge may be more realistic, considering regular usage.
Conclusion
In summary, while the BMW i8 is a pioneer in hybrid electric vehicles, the Tesla Model 3 and Model S are more comparable. The choice between these models ultimately depends on your priorities. If you prioritize cost savings and have issues with the single-screen interface, the Model 3 is an excellent choice. For those seeking a high-performance vehicle with a mix of EV and gasoline technology, the BMW i8 is still worth considering.