Which is Better: Ashok Leyland Ecomet 1212 Strong or Tata LPT 1109?
When choosing between Ashok Leyland Ecomet 1212 Strong and Tata LPT 1109, it's important to consider various factors including performance, maintenance, and resale value. Both trucks are designed for 8 tonnes carrying capacity, but their features and reliability can significantly impact your decision.
Technical Specifications
Both trucks have a Gross Vehicle Weight (GVW) of 11,990 kg. The Ashok Leyland Ecomet 1212 Strong produces 130 rpm, whereas the Tata LPT 1109 Ex produces 123 rpm. While the LPT 1109 has a slight edge in power, the Ecomet 1212 is known for its robust and reliable engineering.
Performance and Reliability
When it comes to performance and reliability, there are some notable differences. The Ashok Leyland Ecomet 1212 Strong is known for its superior built quality and higher reliability. This is particularly important for long-term ownership and endurance in various operating conditions.
However, the LPT 1109 is favored for its lower maintenance requirements and good resale value. These factors can significantly reduce operational costs and increase the truck's lifecycle value.
Clutch Plate Comparison
One critical aspect to consider is the clutch plate. The Ecomet 1212 Strong typically needs a new clutch plate every 60,000 km, compared to the LPT 1109, which can go up to 125,000 km without any clutch issues. This discrepancy can make a significant difference in terms of downtime and repair costs.
Personal Preference and Recommendations
Based on personal experience and feedback from drivers, I recommend the Ashok Leyland new model 1214. This model offers a payload of 10 tonnes and demonstrates superior performance in the market. It has been a hot-selling product, with drivers consistently providing positive feedback. The 1214 model is also tested by me, offering an economy of 6.5 kmpl at a 9-ton loading capacity.
Comparing Ecomet 1212 Strong and LPT 1109
When comparing the Ecomet 1212 Strong and the LPT 1109, the Ecomet 1212 Strong stands out for its higher reliability, lower maintenance requirements, and the advanced iEGR technology. The LPT 1109, on the other hand, uses a traditional EGR system, which has its own set of disadvantages. Ashok Leyland has significantly improved the performance of the LPT 1109 by introducing the iEGR intelligent EGR system, which addresses the limitations of the traditional system.
If you are looking for a more powerful and reliable truck, the Ecomet 1212 Strong is preferable. It offers better acceleration and a more robust build, despite the slight power difference.
Application and Load Tonnage
Consider the type of routes you will be traveling and the load tonnage you need to carry. If extended duration driving or heavy loads are part of your daily routine, the Ecomet 1212 Strong might be the better choice. However, if maintenance and resale value are more critical, the LPT 1109 could be a more economical option.
For those considering a 4-cylinder truck with higher payload and better ground clearance, the Ashok Leyland Ecomet 1214 is a compelling alternative. This model offers a more substantial payload and improved performance, making it a top choice for demanding applications.
Conclusion: While both trucks have their merits, the Ecomet 1212 Strong and Ecomet 1214 by Ashok Leyland stand out for their reliability, performance, and advanced technology. If you prioritize maintenance and resale value, the LPT 1109 is still a solid choice. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and operational environment.